Jennifer Lagner wins 2-0 coin toss against Lisa Herrold for Florida seat
Florida law allows tied elections to be settled by chance; Lagner won both coin tosses against Lisa Herrold.
Jennifer Lagner won an Atlantic Beach, Florida, City Commission seat on Nov. 13 in a coin toss after tying Lisa Herrold with 3,162 votes apiece.
The Seat 4 contest had remained tied through machine and manual recounts ordered by Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland after the Nov. 3 election.
One ballot could have settled it. Election officials received it from overseas on Nov. 12, but the voter left the Atlantic Beach commission race blank.
"It's remarkable, really...the meaning of that is every vote matters, you know, and one vote can make a difference," Holland said.
Holland told Action News Jax that Duval County had seen one previous tied election. "It hasn't happened in about 14 years, and never before," he said.
That earlier tie occurred in 2014, when a Neptune Beach City Council contest between Rory Diamond and Richard Arthur went to a drawing of numbered ping-pong balls. Arthur chose the higher-numbered ball and won.
Florida law permits tied elections to be settled by lot, or a game of chance. For the Atlantic Beach race, the candidates would each call one of the first two coin tosses, with the winner determined by the best two out of three.
The rules required the coin to land in the middle of a square mat for a toss to count. About a dozen people gathered outside the supervisor of elections office to watch Holland flip his office's challenge coin, which he first held up to show the tails side.
Herrold called heads on the opening flip, but it landed tails and gave Lagner the first win, according to Fox News and NDTV. Lagner then chose heads, and the coin landed heads.
The Times of India described the calls in a different order but also said Lagner won both tosses. Her 2-0 win eliminated the need for a third flip, and the tiebreaker lasted roughly 20 seconds.
It was not immediately known when the result will be formally certified or when Lagner will be sworn in.
Lagner told Action News Jax that the result "shows how great and free our country is."
On Facebook on Nov. 13, she wrote that she was "honored to have the opportunity to serve as your next City Commissioner for Seat 4." Lagner described the toss in that post as "an unexpected and unforgettable way to bring an election to a close" and thanked Holland "and his entire team for their work throughout this election process."
Herrold said she and Lagner had belonged to the community for years and that the result "was meant to be." The candidates hugged during the tiebreaker.
"We're going to look back at this and realize how unbelievable this was," Herrold said.






