Search

Crime

Pontins parent fined £1m after Brean Sands ceiling collapse killed grandmother

A 2016 survey had warned that the ceiling at Brean Sands could collapse, but only minor work followed.

Bristol Crown Court's stone tower and arched entrances viewed from across the street (file photo, 2021)
Bristol Crown Court's stone tower and arched entrances viewed from across the street (file photo, 2021) Photo: Bristol Crown Court by Anthony O'Neil / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0 (modified) · License

Pontins' parent company Britannia Jinky Jersey was fined £1m on Friday over a ceiling collapse at a Somerset holiday park that led to the death of a 68-year-old grandmother.

At Bristol Crown Court, contractor Stephen Bennison, 60, of Farington in Lancashire, received a 10-month prison sentence suspended for 18 months.

"It was an accident waiting to happen," Judge Neil Moody said, adding that "cutting costs at expense of safety was a factor." Moody found Bennison had been chosen because his bid was cheaper than others.

Wendy Jones, of Hereford, was in her mobility scooter among about 100 people playing bingo that evening, Feb. 20, 2019. Inside the Fun Factory at Pontins' Brean Sands park, ventilation ducting fell along with a 40m (131ft) stretch of ceiling.

Jones' daughter, Hayley Kendall, was waiting at the bar when she heard a "loud bang" and saw fallen wood, metal and yellow foam insulation, the court heard. BBC News and The Guardian counted 18 injured people, while The Independent put the figure at 16.

Police said Jones sustained a punctured lung, broken ribs and fractures to her femur and shoulder. Her injuries were not initially thought to be life-threatening, but she died on Aug. 4, 2019, after almost six months in hospital. A post-mortem examination established a clear link between her death and the injuries at Pontins.

"An accident is something unforeseeable," her son, James Havard-Jones, said, adding that his mother's death "was preventable."

The company pleaded not guilty to a corporate manslaughter charge, Avon and Somerset Police said. At a September hearing, the Crown Prosecution Service accepted its guilty plea to an alternative charge of failing in its public safety duty under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. Bennison pleaded guilty to an offence under that act.

Parked cars outside low buildings at Pontins Brean Sands, with trees and a roller coaster beyond (file photo, 2008)
Parked cars outside low buildings at Pontins Brean Sands, with trees and a roller coaster beyond (file photo, 2008). Photo: Carl Farnell / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0 (cropped) · License

The court ordered the company to pay £72,345 in prosecution costs, while Bennison must pay £1,000.

Investigators traced the collapse to soundproofing work begun in 2015 over noise disturbance concerns. They found the duct had been poorly fitted decades before Britannia Jinky Jersey took over the site in 2011.

Bennison operated a sound and lighting company but had never installed sound insulation slabs before. More than four tonnes of surplus slabs and plasterboard fascias were needlessly placed on the ducting.

Bennison told officers he put the slabs there to dispose of surplus pallets and had no structural qualifications, police said. He assured Pontins management the added weight was safe, but a survey in 2016 raised concerns about the ceiling grid being overloaded and slabs placed on the ducting, police said.

Moody said a chartered surveyor's 2016 report found the soundproofing was not "adequately installed" and "could result in a collapse of the ceiling," and Bennison "essentially rejected" it. The only subsequent work was minor and confined to the ceiling grid.

Police said holidaymakers warned staff in the days before the collapse that the ducting was bowing, and some shifted seats away, but the concerns were not escalated. A BBC News investigation found that a former Brean Sands site manager had told Pontins' head office he feared the ceiling would fall.

It was not immediately known whether the company or Bennison would appeal.

After the case, Havard-Jones said the fine was "substantial and should serve as a lesson to other companies that they have to behave properly."

Sources

Latest from Inquisitr

Front page