Search

Politics

Judge lets Trump's $15 billion Times lawsuit proceed over book

Four counts involving seven accusations of criminal conduct can proceed; claims involving two articles were dismissed.

The New York Times name stretches across the metal-screened facade of its headquarters above lit windows (file photo, 2007)
The New York Times name stretches across the metal-screened facade of its headquarters above lit windows (file photo, 2007) Photo: Haxorjoe / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 (cropped) · License

President Donald Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times can advance over a book by two Times reporters, a federal judge ruled Thursday, while dismissing claims involving two articles.

U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday in Tampa, Florida, rejected an attempt by the Times and Penguin Random House to have the entire case dismissed. Former President George H.W. Bush appointed Merryday. The articles at issue were written by Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, and by Peter Baker, the paper's chief White House correspondent.

The surviving case concerns "Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father's Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success," a 2024 book by Buettner and Craig. Merryday found that Trump plausibly alleged the reporters had insufficient support for statements suggesting he committed complex tax crimes.

"In other words, they know that they don't know, but they are undeterred," Merryday wrote of the authors.

Merryday faulted Craig and Buettner for making definitive assertions of complex tax fraud and money laundering without obtaining a formal legal opinion or forensic auditing, Fox News reported. The judge noted that the accusations against Trump and his father came without charges or convictions.

"Knowing of the necessity for that opinion but failing to procure that opinion is a fine example of the purposeful avoidance of the truth," Merryday wrote.

He also rejected the Times' reliance on outside commentators, among them a professor who called a Trump transaction "suspicious" and a former prosecutor who said it "smells like a crime."

Claims narrowed

Merryday dismissed two claims and narrowed four others. Four counts involving seven specific accusations of criminal conduct can proceed.

The judge ruled that 27 other challenged statements were not actionable under the First Amendment protections of New York Times Co. v. Sullivan. He denied Trump's request to amend his complaint a third time.

Both sides welcomed parts of the ruling.

"These defendants will now have to answer for intentionally and maliciously defaming President Trump," a spokesman for Trump's legal team said. He told Fox News Digital the ruling was "a victory for honesty in America."

A Times spokesperson told Fox News Digital the paper was "encouraged to see Judge Merryday's dismissal of almost all claims against us."

"We continue to believe the remaining claim in the filing has no legal merit," Times spokesperson Charlie Stadtlander told The Hill.

The legal standard

Trump sued in September 2025 over accounts of his business career, including what he inherited from his father and his part in creating the reality show "The Apprentice." His suit accuses the Times and Penguin Random House of harming his reputation through false stories about his business acumen before the 2024 presidential election.

Both defendants deny defaming Trump. In seeking dismissal, they argued that some statements were opinions that could not be proved true or false. They described the case in a court filing as legally flawed and intended to score political points. Before the ruling, Penguin Random House called the suit "meritless" and said it "stands by the book and its authors."

The Supreme Court's 1964 Sullivan decision requires public officials who sue for defamation to prove "actual malice." That means defendants knew a statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for its truth. Merryday said Trump may be able to meet that standard by proving the reporters knowingly made false statements about him.

The case is at an early evidentiary stage. Lawyers for both sides told Merryday in July that their fact-finding had been limited and they had taken no depositions. Once discovery is complete, the parties may seek a ruling on the evidence, and a jury could hear any claims that remain.

The Times must file its formal answer to the complaint within 28 days.

Sources

Latest from Inquisitr

Front page