Search

Politics

Transport Workers Union sues Mamdani minutes after carriage ban signing

The federal lawsuit followed the mayor's signing of a law that gives horse-drawn carriages until June 1, 2028, to leave city streets.

Zohran Mamdani speaks at a microphone in front of congestion-pricing signs (2026)
Zohran Mamdani speaks at a microphone in front of congestion-pricing signs (2026) Photo: Metropolitan Transportation Authority / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0 (cropped) · License

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed legislation Thursday to end the city’s horse-drawn carriage industry, and the drivers’ union sued in federal court minutes later.

The measure, Romanch’s Law, gives carriages until June 1, 2028, to leave city streets. Its namesake, Romanch Mahajan, was an 18-year-old tourist from India who died after a startled horse threw him from a carriage in Central Park in June.

A spreading tree frames the Gothic Arch above a sunlit bridle path in Central Park (file photo, 2005)
A spreading tree frames the Gothic Arch above a sunlit bridle path in Central Park (file photo, 2005). Photo: Jet Lowe / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

“Our city has changed and now it is time for our laws to change, too,” Mamdani said at the City Hall signing ceremony. He said horses should no longer pull tourists through a crowded Central Park alongside joggers, cyclists and other passersby, NBC New York reported. The Transport Workers Union argues in its Manhattan lawsuit that the law is unconstitutional and that the city violated local legal procedures when it approved the measure.

The lawsuit names Mamdani and other city officials as defendants. “The City's approach can be summarized in twelve words: immediately cripple the owners, ignore property interests and contracts, and maybe compensate,” the suit states. A city law department spokesperson said the department is reviewing the case.

“This bill is a train wreck of constitutional and due process violations,” union President John Samuelsen said before the signing. He said the measure offers drivers and carriage owners nothing concrete. “It is not progressive. It is anti-worker. It's theft,” he said.

The Central Park accident

NBC New York reported that the driver had left the horse to photograph a family when the animal was spooked, bolted and overturned the carriage.

In July, Romanch’s father, Deepak Mahajan, appeared by Zoom at a City Council hearing and urged lawmakers to approve the bill. “We came to New York as a family of four. We are learning to cope with life as a family of three,” he said at the hearing, according to the Daily Mail.

Council Member Christopher Marte, who sponsored the bill, said Thursday, “We cannot bring Romanch Mahajan back, but we can honor his family's call to prevent another tragedy.”

The council passed the measure 40-7 in October. City Council Speaker Julie Menin said Thursday, “This is a truly historic day for New York City, nearly two decades after the Council first considered ending the horse-drawn carriage industry.”

President Donald Trump wrote on Truth Social in October that it was “So sad to see the beloved Central Park Horse-drawn Carriage Industry ending after over a Century, based largely on one tragic accident.”

Worker support and horse retirement

On Tuesday, Mamdani’s administration announced a transition plan covering roughly 200 workers affected by the ban, including medallion owners, carriage drivers and stable hands. The plan calls for buying medallions from their owners and providing career assistance to drivers and stable hands. Mamdani said city stipends would pay for workers to take job-training and career-development classes.

New York City Hall’s domed tower rises above its columned entrance and broad steps (file photo, 2007)
New York City Hall’s domed tower rises above its columned entrance and broad steps (file photo, 2007). Photo: Momos / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 (cropped) · License

Samuelsen said Thursday, “Despite the good intentions of the mayor, the protections he outlined recently should have been written into the legislation.” After the plan was announced Tuesday, he warned that the initiatives “could quickly be abandoned in a fiscal crisis.”

The law prohibits the slaughter of carriage horses. Allie Taylor, director of the Mayor's Office of Animal Welfare, said, “As we work to support carriage drivers through this transition, we have sanctuaries and rescue organizations ready to welcome the horses into retirement.”

Mamdani will direct his administration to study whether electric carriages and electric pedal-assist bicycles are feasible in Central Park. The Central Park Conservancy told CBS News it preferred a fleet of pedicabs operating throughout the year. Heavy electric vehicles “would come at the expense of the regular New Yorkers who run, walk, bike and stroll through it,” the conservancy said.

According to USA Today, New York is the largest U.S. metropolitan area to prohibit carriage rides, following bans in Philadelphia, Chicago and San Antonio in the last five years.

The administration said it would publish the full transition plan by April 2027 and incorporate feedback from the Transport Workers Union and carriage workers.

Sources

Latest from Inquisitr

Front page