Search

Politics

Justice Department moves to end Alaska suit after Mary Peltola wins 50.13%

Mary Peltola won 50.13% of the vote, enough for an outright majority without a ranked-choice count.

Mary Peltola speaks at a lectern in front of red and white flag stripes (file photo, 2023)
Mary Peltola speaks at a lectern in front of red and white flag stripes (file photo, 2023) Photo: Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson / Flickr, Public Domain Mark 1.0

The Justice Department asked a federal appeals court Thursday to declare its effort to block certification of Alaska’s U.S. Senate race moot, pointing to Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory two days earlier.

The department had sued before the midterms to prevent certification unless Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan won. Its challenge focused on another candidate with the same name, Dan J. Sullivan, who taught school before retiring in the fishing community of Petersburg.

Peltola received 50.13% of the vote, enough for an outright majority and more than the three other candidates combined, so no ranked-choice count was needed. The votes for either Sullivan consequently did not alter the result, as NBC News noted.

The department said the second Sullivan’s ballots are now mixed with the others. “The United States therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means of determin[ing] whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan,” its attorneys wrote.

Federal attorneys asked the 9th Circuit to vacate the lower court’s dismissal order, which would erase the ruling. They wrote that the suit “was always to make sure that voters had the opportunity to cast a vote accurately reflecting their choice of candidate.” They attributed “the confusion caused (and intended to be caused) by Daniel J. Sullivan's campaign, egged on by Peltola's” to the two campaigns.

Peltola said in a statement that voters “sent a very clear message about the direction they want our state to go in.” “I'm eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans,” she said.

Her victory gives Democrats 56 seats in the coming Senate and marked their ninth Senate pickup in the midterms. Peltola, who is Yup'ik, will be the first Alaska Native to serve in the Senate.

The lawsuit and its aftermath

The department sued in October at President Donald Trump’s direction, arguing that officials should not certify a Peltola win until an investigation established whether voters were confused. “I'm the one that said do it,” Trump told reporters that month.

The Robert F. Kennedy Department of Justice Building rises above a Washington, D.C., intersection under a blue sky (2026)
The Robert F. Kennedy Department of Justice Building rises above a Washington, D.C., intersection under a blue sky (2026). Photo: APK / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0 (cropped) · License

The administration never explained how officials could examine possible voter confusion given the secrecy of ballots, The Associated Press reported. The New York Times reported several days into the lawsuit that messages and other records appeared to show Peltola’s campaign was involved in recruiting the second Sullivan.

On Oct. 28, Trump called the matter “voter fraud at the highest level.” He said Peltola “should be removed from the ballot and prosecuted, and so should the fake Dan Sullivan.”

Peltola has denied encouraging the candidacy, while Dan J. Sullivan has long said he ran independently. Alaska generally permits ballot stacking and the promotion of spoiler candidates. In June, before the federal case, the Alaska Supreme Court ruled that Dan J. Sullivan could remain on the ballot.

Attorneys for Alaska’s Republican-controlled government opposed the federal suit as meritless and sought its dismissal. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case, and the department appealed.

Gleason found that the government lacked standing, the Alaska Beacon reported. NPR reported that she concluded the requested order would clearly violate Alaskan voters’ right to a secret ballot.

On appeal, the League of Women Voters of Alaska and Common Cause asked the 9th Circuit to summarily uphold the dismissal and punish the federal attorneys who filed the case. “The legal theory advanced by the United States here is embarrassing and indefensible,” American Civil Liberties Union attorneys for the groups wrote earlier.

The Beacon, citing the Anchorage Daily News, reported that the Alaska Bureau of Investigation and the FBI are investigating whether laws were broken in the second Sullivan’s recruitment.

Alaska Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher said Wednesday that she intends to certify the election, including Peltola’s win, next week.

Sources

Latest from Inquisitr

Front page