Speculation is intensifying that a potential retirement on the Supreme Court could hand President Donald Trump another major opportunity to shape the direction of the nation’s highest court. With Republicans currently maintaining control of Congress and therefore overseeing the confirmation process, the timing of any Supreme Court vacancy could prove decisive.
Justice Samuel Alito, 75, has served on the Supreme Court since January 2006 after being nominated by President George W. Bush. At the end of January, he marked 20 years on the bench during the Trump administration — a milestone achieved by relatively few justices in modern history. His two decades of service, combined with his age, have fueled growing discussion that he may be weighing whether to step down.
Historically, the average tenure for a Supreme Court justice has been about 16 years, though since the 1970s justices have increasingly remained on the bench longer due to advances in healthcare and longer life expectancy. Data shows that many justices tend to retire in their late seventies or early eighties. NYU law professor Melissa Murray recently observed that reaching that age range is “usually a very good milestone on which to retire,” reflecting common historical patterns prior to the Trump presidency.
If Alito were to retire this year while Republicans still hold control of Congress — and thus the Senate confirmation process — Trump and GOP leaders could move quickly to confirm a conservative successor. Murray explained the strategic advantage of such timing, stating, “If you retire before you lose the Senate, then you make the whole glide path so much easier for getting in your preferred candidate.” She added pointedly, “Do it before the midterms change everything.”
Photos of Trump the family man- because first and foremost he’s a husband, father and grandfather. A man of flesh and blood who deserves better than our nation has given him. God bless President Trump. Send him some love. ❤️ 🇺🇸🙌🏽🇺🇸 pic.twitter.com/bkLFpKNOEo
— Shannon 🇺🇸I stand with America (@thewriterme) February 12, 2026
Such a move would almost certainly preserve and potentially deepen Trump and conservative control over the Supreme Court. Murray acknowledged the broader implications, saying, “This is obviously someone that wants to ensure that he is replaced by a like-minded successor.” Replacing Alito with a younger conservative jurist would not alter the current ideological balance but would extend its durability well into the future.
The prior appointments by Donald Trump to the Supreme Court significantly reshaped the Court’s composition, creating a 6–3 conservative majority. Those justices have participated in landmark rulings involving executive authority, administrative agency power, constitutional interpretation, and social policy. Another appointment would further entrench that majority, potentially influencing American jurisprudence for decades.
Donald Trump’s official Presidential portrait unveiled. pic.twitter.com/dhnLxCorT1
— JOSH DUNLAP (@JDunlap1974) January 16, 2025
Adding to the intrigue surrounding Alito’s future is his forthcoming book, scheduled for publication in October 2026 — a period that coincides with the typically demanding opening of the Court’s annual term. Supreme Court justices are usually occupied with oral arguments and high-profile cases during that time. Murray noted the unusual timing, stating, “The publication for his forthcoming book … published during the first week of October term 2026 … that is usually a time when sitting justices are quite busy.” She continued, “Which means it’s not exactly a great time to release your book if you want to promote said book.”
🚨Just in: There is speculation Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito is considering retiring soon
Via: USA Today pic.twitter.com/UHTqDdoCzX
— The Calvin Coolidge Project (@TheCalvinCooli1) February 17, 2026
The scheduling has prompted questions among observers about whether the timing signals broader plans before the end of the Trump administration. While Alito has not publicly announced any retirement decision, the convergence of his 20-year milestone, his age, Republican control of the Senate, and the upcoming book release has intensified political and legal speculation.
If Alito ultimately decides that this is the right moment to conclude his service, Trump would once again be positioned to nominate a justice aligned with originalist and textualist principles. Given the lifetime nature of Supreme Court appointments, such a nomination could secure conservative leadership of the Court for a generation or more — further cementing Trump’s enduring impact on the highest court in the land
