Life works in mysterious ways. This is absolutely true for an abduction case that remained unresolved for more than four decades, which has finally found some closure.
A Kentucky woman was accused of kidnapping her own daughter, changing her identity, and starting a new life in another state after abandoning her husband and other family members.
The case from April 1983 revolves around a woman named Debra Newton, who was arrested on December 15, 2025 at her residence in Marion County, Florida. She faces felony custodial interference charges for allegedly fleeing Louisville, Kentucky, with her 3-year-old daughter, Michelle Marie Newton.
According to Atlanta Black Star, Debra Newton reportedly told her husband, Joe Newton, that she was moving to Georgia for a new job. Instead, she disappeared with their child and cut off contact with Joe and her other family members.
View this post on Instagram
She also got into legal trouble for custodial interference. She became the subject of an FBI Unlawful Flight to Avoid Prosecution warrant. At one point, Newton was listed among the FBI’s top parental-kidnapping fugitives.
Despite repeated attempts by Joe Newton and the family, the case went cold in 2000 as it wasn’t progressing. Michelle was removed from the missing persons database. In 2016, the investigation was reopened at the request of a family member, and Michelle was finally found in 2025.
This year, a golden lead was found regarding the decades-old case. Detectives received a tip through Crime Stoppers suggesting that Newton was living in Marion County under the name “Sharon Nearly.”
Investigators later confirmed through images and DNA provided by Newton’s sister that “Sharon” was, in fact, Debra Newton. Body-camera footage showed Debra chatting with a friend while walking her dog outside her home on November 24.
WOMAN ARRESTED 40 YEARS after allegedly kidnapping her daughter from the father’s legal custody. It was an astounding case. Police busted 66-year-old Debra Newton in Florida. Police say Newton kidnapped her 3-year-old daughter Michelle in Louisville, Kentucky in 1983 and then… pic.twitter.com/Z3Svm7wm8G
— Donnie Cope (@dcopechatter) December 21, 2025
The cops approached the duo as the neighbor joked about Sharon without realizing that they actually came to arrest her. As per The New York Post, the neighbor said, “Uh-oh — they’re coming for you, Sharon!”
The neighbor laughed, using the name Newton had gone by for years. “They don’t want me,” Debra Newton replied before turning to the officers and nervously asking what was happening.
Marion County Sheriff then told them that they were there to arrest her with a warrant. “We’re here for you, ma’am. Definitely here for you.” Even then, the neighbor could not believe it and kept on joking about the situation until she was told that they were serious.
“You’re not who you think you are,” officers told her. “You’re a missing person. You’re Michelle Marie Newton.” The 66-year-old had reportedly remarried and lived in Florida’s largest retirement community, known as The Villages.
40-Year Cold Case Solved: Missing Girl Found, Mother Arrested Under Alias
On April 2, 1983, Debra Leigh Newton abducted her 3-year-old daughter, Michelle Marie Newton, from Louisville, Kentucky, after telling her husband she was moving for a job in Georgia. The pair vanished,… pic.twitter.com/wL6XnzwGRd
— Police Incidents (@PoliceIncident) December 18, 2025
Michelle, who is now 46, was stunned when police informed her as an adult that she was a missing child and that her identity had been changed. She met her father, Joe Newton, over Thanksgiving and reunited with her “real family.”
“She’s always been in my heart,” Joe said as he spoke to the media. Michelle, whose name had also been changed while she lived in Florida, was not upset or furious at her mother upon knowing the truth.
She told NBC News that while healing and accepting the truth may take time, she hopes to reconnect with her family members she never knew. The motive behind Debra’s life-altering move remains unclear at the time of writing. Still, she is scheduled to return to court on January 23, 2026.
