Search

Entertainment

IndieWire says Brad Pitt's 'Cliff Booth' complicates Netflix Oscar campaign

IndieWire sees potential for Elizabeth Debicki in supporting actress, but says 10 nominations are out of reach.

Brad Pitt in a black jacket at a public event (file photo, 2024)
Brad Pitt in a black jacket at a public event (file photo, 2024) Photo: Harald Krichel / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 (modified) · License

Netflix’s “The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth” earned praise after its Los Angeles premiere Monday, but IndieWire argued Tuesday that the Brad Pitt sequel complicates the streamer’s Oscar campaign.

Pitt reprises the role that earned him a best supporting actor Oscar in Quentin Tarantino’s 2019 “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood.” The original received 10 Oscar nominations, with best picture among them, while David Fincher directed the sequel from Tarantino’s script.

For awards purposes alone, Netflix could have postponed the late-November release until next year, IndieWire argued. Netflix acquired “La Bola Negra” at Cannes after its directors, Los Javis, won best director there. The film went on to become Netflix’s first winner of the People’s Choice Award at the Toronto International Film Festival.

IndieWire said awards prognosticators expect “La Bola Negra” to win best international feature for Spain and land a best picture nomination. Netflix’s international feature contender for South Korea is Lee Chang-dong’s “Possible Love,” which won the Venice Grand Jury Prize. With enough support from critics’ groups, IndieWire said, “Possible Love” could make a second Netflix best picture nomination highly plausible.

Netflix had to release “Cliff Booth” around Thanksgiving, IndieWire wrote, because it was already due to take Imax screens originally secured for Greta Gerwig’s Narnia film. The sequel opens exclusively in Imax theaters Nov. 25, followed by its Netflix streaming debut Dec. 23.

Critics post first reactions

Netflix permitted brief reactions on social media following the premiere, before the Nov. 19 embargo on full reviews, The Hollywood Reporter reported. TheWrap’s Drew Taylor wrote on X that “Tarantino and Fincher are like peanut butter and chocolate (the peanut butter is profane and the chocolate dipped in blood).”

Variety’s Clayton Davis described the film as “a wild, hilarious hangout movie.” In reactions published by Variety, Davis also wrote, “If the 2019 film was a love letter to L.A., this one is a full-on sonnet.”

Critics Choice member Ricky Vàlero called it “an absolute banger” and “one of the year's best films.”

Tarantino script, Fincher cut

Tarantino wrote the screenplay but chose not to direct under his retirement plan, which calls for him to make only one more feature. Netflix purchased the script in 2025 and hired Fincher as director.

In an October interview with Empire magazine, Fincher said Tarantino’s initial draft was 230 pages long and that he removed 60 pages. Fincher has said the script’s length nearly led to a Netflix series instead of a film.

The sequel takes place in 1977, eight years after “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood.” Pitt’s Booth now works part time as a stuntman and takes on odd, sometimes dangerous jobs in Los Angeles. Timothy Olyphant returns as Western actor James Stacy, the only other star from the original to reprise a role.

Craft categories and Debicki

IndieWire wrote that the sequel looked like a home run on paper but amounted to a double or triple in execution. If audiences see it as a hangout movie instead of a cinematic event, the outlet argued, its campaign should target production design and costume design. Its crew includes Oscar-winning cinematographer Erik Messerschmidt, editor Kirk Baxter and composers Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross.

The outlet wrote that there is no rush to nominate Pitt again for a part that already earned him an Oscar. It called Emmy winner Elizabeth Debicki’s performance the film’s best and said she could earn her first Oscar nomination for supporting actress, a category without a current consensus.

IndieWire concluded that the sequel’s late-year arrival and limited theatrical reach put the original’s 10 nominations out of reach.

Tarantino presented 17 minutes of footage at AFI Fest in late October and will release a novel, “The Adventures of Cliff Booth,” for Harper this December.

Sources

Latest from Inquisitr

Front page