Billy Evans says Amanda Seyfried judged his relationship from edited footage
Evans said he and Elizabeth Holmes believed they were extending an olive branch by meeting Seyfried on camera.

Billy Evans, the partner of imprisoned Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes, told The Hollywood Reporter that Amanda Seyfried formed opinions from edited footage without spending time with them as a couple.
Seyfried won an Emmy for portraying Holmes in Hulu’s “The Dropout.” She plays herself and reprises the role in reenactments in “You Can See Everything,” an A24 documentary by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim that reached theaters on Oct. 16.
“I’ve heard she was going through a lot in her life at the time in which this was being filmed, so I can understand why she’d view our relationship through a different lens than reality,” Evans said in the interview.
Evans said her conduct toward him “made more sense to me after seeing the film, and hearing her say, ‘I want to break them up,’” adding that he had believed he and Holmes “were extending an olive branch” by meeting her on camera.
The film shows the meeting at dinner, where Evans insulted Seyfried’s acting and the pair disagreed about her criticism of Charlie Kirk after Kirk was killed in 2025.
Evans said he and Holmes did not hold Seyfried responsible for her portrayal, since she had not written the script or conducted the research, “or lack thereof.”
He rejected suggestions that he controlled Holmes through power of attorney, saying her imprisonment left him to manage certain legal and financial duties while bringing up their two children.
“If other people are unhappy about our relationship, I suggest that they invest more time in their own,” Evans said.
Seyfried said in an earlier Rolling Stone interview that she thought even less of Evans after their meeting during filming. His conduct in the footage “felt yucky to me,” she said, adding that she disliked how he used Holmes “as a tool.” Seyfried said she had not developed the same rapport with Evans that Fielder had.
It was not immediately known whether Seyfried or her representatives had responded to Evans’ latest comments.
Evans, 34, spoke with CBS News chief correspondent Matt Gutman on “Sunday Morning” in his first interview since the documentary’s release. The CBS interview aired Sunday.
“I’m really glad that they included her because it shows what a difference there is between the real thing and how eager she was to play a character,” Evans said. Asked whether Seyfried played Holmes well, he said he was “glad Nathan was there to help her.”
“Doesn’t seem like you hold very high opinion of her acting, or of her as a person,” Gutman said.
“Matt, I’m gonna do my best not to speak poorly about other people right now, because I’ve had a lot of people do that about me recently, and I know how it feels,” Evans said.
Evans also told CBS he was not “some controlling monster who’s leveraging his wife.”
He said his family receives constant threats of violence and recounted an encounter at a stop light, where a man screamed at him as he drove his children to school.
“I know where you live. I know who you are. I know where your kids sleep, and the things that I will do to you,” Evans recalled the man saying.
Holmes, 42, is serving an 11-year federal sentence in Texas. In 2022, she was convicted on four counts of wire fraud for misrepresenting Theranos’ technology to investors.
A24’s awards site shows the studio is entering the documentary in categories that include best picture and campaigning for Seyfried as supporting actress. The film is eligible for best documentary feature at the 99th Academy Awards.
Sources
- Variety: Billy Evans Addresses Amanda Seyfried’s Portrayal of Elizabeth Holmes in ‘You Can See Everything’: She Was ‘Eager’ to ‘Play a Character’
- Los Angeles Times: Elizabeth Holmes’ partner Billy Evans breaks silence after A24 documentary backlash
- NBC News: Billy Evans, Elizabeth Holmes’ partner, says he gets threats after ‘You Can See Everything’






