twitter-brett-kavanaugh-sea-world-whale-trainer

Twitter Slams Brett Kavanaugh For SeaWorld Opinion Seeming To Blame Mutilated Whale Trainer For Her Own Death

Jonathan Vankin - Author
By

Jul. 10 2018, Updated 11:08 a.m. ET

Donald Trump’s new United States Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh has written and issued opinions on a wide range of legal and Constitutional issues, with much of the attention around his nomination centered on his news concerning a woman’s right to abortion, as The Washington Post reported, and how he might rule on issues relating to presidential power — which could determine Trump’s fate in the ongoing Russia collusion investigation.

As The Atlantic reported, Kavanaugh has supported sweeping power for the president, believing that a president can “neither be sued, indicted, tried, investigated or even questioned by prosecutors while in office.” Which would be good news for Trump, who faces all of those possibilities.

Article continues below advertisement

But there was one case in particular that caught the attention of Twitter users after writer Amanda Marcotte posted about it on her Twitter account, noting that Kavanaugh dissented from a majority opinion written by Judge Merrick Garland — who had been President Barack Obama’s nominee to the court in 2016, only to have the nomination declared, as NPR described, “null and void” by Senate Republican Majority Leader Mitch McConnell. Garland never even received a hearing before the Senate.

The case noted by Marcotte involved the death of a whale trainer, Dawn Brancheau, at the SeaWorld aquatic theme park. As reported by ABC News, Brancheau was killed on February 24, 2010, by the orca whale Tilikum — who later became the subject of a critically acclaimed documentary about SeaWorld’s treatment of captive whales, Blackfish.

https://twitter.com/SeaWorldTyler/status/835336560857903104

The federal government’s Occupation and Safety Health Administration saddled SeaWorld with heavy fines for safety violations resulting in Brancheau’s death, and the theme park sued to get the fines revoked. Judge Judith Rogers’ opinion, joined by Garland, upheld the fines, as Florida’s WKMG TV News reported. But in a dissent, Kavanaugh seemed to blame Brancheau, not the theme park, for her own death.

Article continues below advertisement

“Many sports events and entertainment shows can be extremely dangerous for the participants. Football. Ice hockey. Downhill skiing. Air shows. The circus. Horse racing. Tiger taming. Standing in the batter’s box against a 95 mile per hour fastball,” Kavanaugh wrote in his dissent. “But the participants in those activities want to take part, sometimes even to make a career of it, despite and occasionally because of the known risk of serious injury.”

That’s what prompted Twitter users to respond, including Marcotte who wondered why Kavanaugh did not take into account the conditions of Tilikum’s 33 years of captivity.

https://twitter.com/AmandaMarcotte/status/1016518771866001408

https://twitter.com/MaryEllenMaatma/status/1016550309768949760

https://twitter.com/thelist/status/1016637817261318144

Others simply found Kavanaugh’s reasoning absurd.

Article continues below advertisement
Article continues below advertisement

Or typical of Trump administration policies.

Advertisement

Latest Donald Trump News and Updates

    © Copyright 2023 The Inquisitr. The Inquisitr is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.