Pennsylvania Teacher Had Oral Sex With Student, Love Letter Found On School Printer, Police Allege

Pennsylvania teacher Sarah O’Neill, 35, was caught having an affair with a 16-year-old student after the Church Farm School educator left a love letter to the boy on the office printer. O’Neill and the student were allegedly engaged in a 10-month love affair which included oral sex.

Sarah O’Neill reportedly exchanged 319 texts and 509 phone calls (106 hours of phone conversations total) with the 16-year-old Church Farm School student before the love letter left on the school office printer was found. Pennsylvania police have stated that the teacher and the student “were intimate” in her car, a public park, and hotels. Sarah O’Neill was been charged with four counts of corruption of minors.

teacher sex with student

Church Farm School is a private all boys boarding school in Exton, Pennsylvania. A staff member at the school found the love letter on the office printer after Sarah O’Neill reportedly used the machine. “The thought that I could love so deeply and so wrongly pervaded before you and I even officially began,” the teacher’s love letter to the student said. “It was quite a long winter break before my lips even attempted yours and I wondered if you were as affected as I,” the Pennsylvania English teacher reportedly wrote in the love letter to the student. She was the chair of the Church Farm School English department.

Sarah O’Neill was asked to resign after Church Farm School officials were made aware of the love letter to the student. The English teacher’s affair with the 16-year-old boy allegedly continued after she parted ways with the private school.

The unnamed teen, now 17, said the love affair with his teacher began last January. The pair first kissed at a Motel 6 in King of Prussia in February 2014, according to the student. The Church Farm School teenager also told police officers that he and his teacher had oral sex on multiple occasions at the Motel 6 and at other locations.

A Church Farm School janitor told Pennsylvania law enforcement investigators that he caught Sarah O’Neill and the student in her locked classroom with the lights off three times. On one occasion O’Neill appeared to have ripped pantyhose and she said she was helping the student with an extra credit project, the school custodian added.
In one text to the Pennsylvania teacher the student asked her what she was wearing. Sarah O’Neill replied, “I should be wearing sexy clothing for you when you ask that. Like some tight underwear or nothing. But I am too formal for such outlandishness.”

When teen boy went missing from the Church Farm School campus in November, police officers felt it was clear that he was with O’Neill. When he finally returned to the Pennsylvania boarding school after multiple phone calls to his cell phone and several hours, he told the police that he was having oral sex with his teacher at a local hotel.
Sarah O’Neill was employed at the Church Farm School from September 2007 to June 2014. She is currently out on bond with a court appearance scheduled for February 2.

What do you think about Pennsylvania teacher Sarah O’Neill and the oral sex with her student allegations?

[Images via: and NBC Philadelphia]

Share this article: Pennsylvania Teacher Had Oral Sex With Student, Love Letter Found On School Printer, Police Allege
More from Inquisitr