Search

News

Sotheby's sets Van Gogh auction record with $190.4 million sale

The New York sale followed an agreement between the sellers and heirs who said the painting had been sold under Nazi duress.

Flags above the lit Sotheby’s sign and glass entrance, seen from across the street (file photo, 2022)
Flags above the lit Sotheby’s sign and glass entrance, seen from across the street (file photo, 2022) Photo: ajay_suresh / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

Sotheby's sold a Van Gogh painting for a record $190.4 million on Wednesday after its sellers settled with heirs who said an earlier sale took place under Nazi duress.

The New York auction of Vincent van Gogh's Châtaigniers en fleurs followed an agreement between Argentina's Blaquier-Arrieta family and descendants of Samuel and Hedwig Fischer, a German Jewish couple.

Van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en fleurs, showing flowering chestnut trees above figures on a village road (file photo, 1890)
Van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en fleurs, showing flowering chestnut trees above figures on a village road (file photo, 1890). Photo: Vincent van Gogh / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

"In recognition of the painting's complex Nazi-era history and the suffering endured by the Fischer family during the Holocaust, the two families have reached a mutually satisfactory resolution," Sotheby's said. The auction house cited confidentiality in declining to release the terms.

Sotheby's had valued the work at roughly $180 million ahead of the auction.

Orchard with Cypresses held the previous Van Gogh auction record, having fetched $117.2 million at Christie's in November 2022. It had belonged to the collection of Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen.

Bidding in Manhattan

In a crowded Manhattan salesroom, few potential buyers made bids, and auctioneer Oliver Barker spent more than three minutes trying to attract others, The New York Times reported. Sotheby's controlling shareholder Patrick Drahi watched from behind the audience with what the Times described as a dour expression.

The Times identified art dealer William Acquavella, head of Acquavella Galleries, as the sole prevailing bidder. BBC News said the buyer was not immediately clear.

The sale price includes fees. The Times counted Châtaigniers en fleurs as the sixth most expensive painting ever auctioned, once prices are adjusted for inflation.

Agence France-Presse said no work had fetched more at auction this season.

Van Gogh painted it in Auvers-sur-Oise, France, in 1890, during the final two months of his life. A large chestnut tree blooms in evening light in the painting, which uses blues, yellows and greens.

The Fischer family's claim

Samuel Fischer bought the painting in Paris in 1909. He founded a publishing company whose authors included Thomas Mann and Hermann Hesse, and kept the work until his death in 1934, when it passed down through his family.

The family sold it through a gallery in Amsterdam in 1936. Fischer's heirs say financial losses suffered by the family publishing company under the Nazis forced the sale. The Blaquier-Arrieta family, whose fortune came from sugar, bought the painting in 1975.

The heirs asserted their claim the week before the auction. Their Berlin-based lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, asked Sotheby's for proof that the sale fetched market value and would have happened regardless of Nazi rule.

Schnabel wrote to Sotheby's restitution department head Marco Toracca in a Nov. 12 email that "no auction may take place" unless both conditions were agreed to, People reported, citing an email obtained by The New York Times.

Questions over contact

Some restitution experts questioned why Sotheby's had not approached the Fischer heirs sooner, the Times reported.

Art recovery lawyer Christopher A. Marinello, founder of Art Recovery International, compared forced-sale claims from the Nazi era with outright seizures. "They're a little bit harder to prove, but they certainly carry the same amount of weight," he told NPR.

Marinello told NPR about a client who had to go to Switzerland after World War II to repurchase his own artwork. He recalled dealers saying to original owners, "Oh, we thought you were dead," Marinello told NPR.

"They wanted the Holocaust cases to go away," Marinello told NPR of the art market.

Agreement before the sale

The Fischer heirs and the Blaquier-Arrieta family reached their agreement following a marathon session of negotiations on Monday. Sotheby's said it was "pleased to have helped facilitate this outcome and to see the matter resolved ahead of the sale."

In the Sotheby's release, the heirs said they were "grateful for the trusting and fair negotiation and collaboration with Sotheby's and the Blaquier-Arrieta family." The sellers said they appreciated the "constructive dialogue that made this resolution possible."

Sources

Latest from Inquisitr

Front page