Brett Gardner joins Buster Posey on 2027 Hall of Fame ballot
Gardner won a World Series with the Yankees in 2009 and ranks third on the team's career stolen bases list with 274.

Brett Gardner, who played 14 seasons for the New York Yankees, was among 14 first-time candidates on the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot released Monday, giving him his first chance at election.
The ballot includes 13 returning candidates and is going out this week to more than 400 Baseball Writers' Association of America voters. Election requires 75% of votes cast, a threshold Gardner is unlikely to reach, MLB.com wrote. CBS Sports predicted Gardner and the other first-time candidates behind Buster Posey and Jon Lester will likely miss the 5% required to remain eligible.
Aaron Judge remembers a teammate who helped him settle in. Early in 2017, Judge lived in a Times Square hotel and could get frozen yogurt at midnight without attracting much of a crowd. For part of that season, Gardner offered Judge a place at his Armonk, N.Y., home, away from distractions.
"He was a prankster. He was everything that you look for in a guy to lead the team. He took me in at a young age when I first got here. He treated me like everybody else and showed me respect," Judge said in 2026.
Gardner's pranks ranged from putting mustard in protein smoothies and chili peppers in meals to dismantling the battery of a staff member's Chevrolet Suburban. Judge continues to imitate Gardner's bent-knee, flexed-biceps reply to the Yankee Stadium Roll Call.
Gardner walked on at the College of Charleston before the Yankees picked him in the third round in 2005. He made his Bronx debut three years later. In his second season, he won the 2009 World Series, the Yankees' most recent championship.
From 2008 to 2021, Gardner batted.256 and collected 1,470 hits. His 100 career OPS-plus matched the league average, the New York Post reported.
Gardner stole 274 bases, third on the Yankees' career list behind Hall of Famers Derek Jeter and Rickey Henderson. He paced the American League with 49 steals in 2011, made the 2015 All-Star team and won a Gold Glove in 2016.
In the 2017 postseason, Gardner faced Cleveland closer Cody Allen for 12 pitches before delivering a two-run, ninth-inning single that helped send the Yankees to the American League Championship Series. Afterward, Allen said, "I think every team in baseball could use a Brett Gardner."
Gardner once said, "I played with plenty of guys that were way more talented than I am, but guys that maybe just didn't want it quite as bad."
An hour after the Yankees' last playoff game in 2021, Gardner remained in his dirt-streaked road jersey and said, "You don't know how many chances you'll get to put the uniform on again." He hoped to return in 2022, but the Yankees did not offer him a contract.
The Post reported that Gardner has largely kept out of public view and away from Yankee Stadium since retiring, spending time with family in South Carolina.
It was not immediately known whether Gardner will return to Yankee Stadium or Old-Timers' Day.
Former teammate CC Sabathia once called Gardner "the heart and soul" of his Yankees teams. When the club honored its 2009 champions in 2024, Sabathia said, "Hopefully he can work out whatever he needs to work out and be here."
Ballots require a Dec. 31 postmark. Hall of Fame President Josh Rawitch will announce the results on MLB Network at 6 p.m. on Jan. 19.
Sources
- New York Post: Yankees’ Brett Gardner named to 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot
- CBS Sports: 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot released: 8 things to know, including newcomers, trends and a prediction
- MLB.com: Consummate professional, mentor and prankster, Gardner a first-timer on HOF ballot
- baseballhall.org: 2027 BBWAA Hall of Fame Ballot Announced
- BBWAA Official site of the Baseball Writers' Association of America: Fourteen newcomers join 2027 Hall of Fame ballot - BBWAA






