Search

Entertainment

'Two Strangers' will move Off Broadway to New World Stages

The musical ends its Broadway run Nov. 29, with previews at its new home set to begin March 22, 2027.

A crowd lines the sidewalk outside the signed entrance to New World Stages (file photo, 2007)
A crowd lines the sidewalk outside the signed entrance to New World Stages (file photo, 2007) Photo: Roman SUZUKI / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0 (cropped) · License

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) will leave Broadway for Off Broadway’s New World Stages in spring 2027. The move was revealed during Sunday’s Broadway curtain call.

The musical earned eight 2026 Tony nominations and will give its final Broadway performance Nov. 29 at the Longacre Theatre, a couple of blocks from New World Stages.

The Longacre Theatre's carved stone facade and illuminated marquee advertising The Prom (file photo, 2019)
The Longacre Theatre's carved stone facade and illuminated marquee advertising The Prom (file photo, 2019). Photo: Ajay Suresh from New York, NY, USA / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (cropped) · License

At its new home, previews begin March 22, 2027, followed by an April 4 opening night.

Kit Buchan, Jim Barne’s co-writer on the musical, told theatrely.com during an exit interview that the show failed to win a Tony. He said someone had warned the team that the production would “immediately close” if it did not win a Tony.

“So I was prepared for this grief, a bereavement that didn't arrive,” Buchan said.

The show started Broadway performances on Nov. 1, 2025, before its official opening on Nov. 20, 2025.

The romantic comedy follows Dougal, played by Sam Tutty, a Brit visiting New York for his estranged father’s second wedding, Playbill reported. Christiani Pitts plays Robin, the bride’s sister, who collects Dougal at the airport.

Neither Tutty nor Pitts is expected to make the Off Broadway move. Casting for the New World Stages run has not been announced.

“Two Strangers has become a part of my life in the same way that brushing my teeth has,” Tutty told Theatrely in the exit interview. “I will never not brush my teeth, therefore I will never not do this show,” he said.

The Broadway design team will return for the Off Broadway production. Soutra Gilmour handles scenery and costumes, Jack Knowles lighting, Tony Gayle sound, Lux Pyramid orchestrations and Nick Finlow music supervision.

Tim Jackson directed and choreographed the Broadway show after overseeing its London production.

Kevin McCollum, Tim Johanson, Glass Half Full Productions and Jamie Wilson Productions will produce Off Broadway, having also produced the Broadway run.

The length of the Off Broadway engagement was not immediately known.

Tickets become available Monday at 10 a.m. ET from Telecharge and the New World Stages box office.

The first national tour of Two Strangers is scheduled to start in Providence, Rhode Island, in 2027.

Sources

Latest from Inquisitr

Front page