Federal judge overturns Trump's 4-year student visa limit
Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV found that DHS exceeded its authority and failed to justify abandoning the existing system.

A federal judge in Massachusetts vacated a Trump administration rule Monday that would have limited international students to four years in the United States, regardless of program length.
U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV, appointed by former President George W. Bush, found that the Department of Homeland Security rule violated the Administrative Procedure Act. He called it "arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with law."
DHS issued the rule in July. Students, researchers and professors with F and J visas would have needed extensions to remain beyond four years. The rule would have replaced the decades-old "duration of status" system, under which most student visa holders could stay while maintaining lawful status and making normal program progress.
"Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity — providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States — that Congress sought to permit and encourage," Saylor wrote. "The statute simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program," he wrote.
DHS had said extensions would offer additional chances to detect fraud, security risks and immigration violations, citing past fraud and abuse in the student visa system. Its lawyers said open-ended admission periods prevent officials from regularly checking foreign nationals' compliance with visa conditions.
A coalition of higher education and labor groups, including the United Auto Workers, sued in August. They argued that the rule was arbitrary and would deter foreign students from coming to study in the U.S.
Miriam Feldblum, president and CEO of the Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, called the decision a "clear and important victory" for international students, scholars and their host universities.
Judge rejects fraud rationale
Saylor found that the rule exceeded statutory authority and that DHS had overlooked less burdensome government tools. He found the department's stated aims of national security and fraud prevention bore no reasonable relationship to the F-1 program's nature and purpose.
The judge wrote that DHS had not adequately explained how discretionary renewals for students already in the country for four years would improve fraud detection. Nor had it shown that the benefits outweighed "the immense costs of abandoning the existing system," he wrote.
DHS tracks international students through the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System, a federal database using school and program sponsor reports on enrollment, immigration status and visa compliance. The department said earlier that the system collects data from schools and is "not designed for performing all relevant fraud and security screening."
The rule also would have restricted school transfers, academic program changes and additional degrees, while imposing more immigration reviews.
Saylor wrote that students would effectively be barred from entering the U.S. for another degree at the same or a lower level. DHS recognized legitimate reasons for doing so, he wrote, including "pursuing an M.B.A. after a J.D."
Saylor blocked the rule in September, before it took effect. His Monday decision went further, vacating the rule entirely.
Plaintiffs cite falling enrollment
"If implemented, this rule would have further weakened our ability to attract international talent, disrupted educational plans, and burdened campuses," Feldblum said.
She said the "harmful consequences of the current administration's policy actions and efforts are already evident in the significant declines in international student enrollment and interest we are witnessing."
DHS and the White House did not immediately respond Tuesday to Fox News Digital's requests for comment, Fox News reported.
A study released on the day preceding the ruling found foreign student enrollment at U.S. universities down 15% this semester, The Hill reported. It was not immediately known which study produced the figure.
The case is Presidents' Alliance v. DHS, No. 1:26-cv-13799. McDermott Will & Schulte LLP represents the plaintiffs, while the Department of Justice represents DHS.
It was not immediately known whether the administration will appeal Monday's ruling. The administration has appealed Saylor's September order, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit will consider the policy next, Inside Higher Ed reported.
Sources
- Fox News: Bush-appointed judge torpedoes Trump immigration rule, rips DHS for overstepping its authority
- The Hill: Judge throws out Trump administration rule restricting foreign students’ time in US
- Washington Examiner: Judge throws out DHS rule capping student visa length
- Politico: Judge tosses DHS rule limiting how long foreign students can study in US
- news.bloomberglaw.com: DHS Limits on F-1 Foreign Students’ Stay in US Overturned (1)


