Daniel Roebuck, 63, challenges Chris Columbus' Home Alone screen-test story
Roebuck says Columbus cited a lack of chemistry with Joe Pesci when he fired him from the role of Marv.

Daniel Roebuck, first cast as burglar Marv in "Home Alone," told Entertainment Weekly that director Chris Columbus' account of a "horrible" screen test with Joe Pesci "never ever happened."
Columbus recounted the firing Tuesday on the Wildmen podcast, hosted by his son Brendan Columbus and Dylan Sprouse. He said he had envisioned Pesci and Daniel Stern as the villains, but "we didn't have Dan Stern because the studio wouldn't pay for Dan Stern." Given a choice of only one, he said, he selected Pesci.
"We did a screen test and they were horrible," Columbus said. "Pesci was great. This other kid was, and he was a kid at the time, he was just awful."
Columbus did not identify the actor, whom he called "the only person I ever had to fire." Roebuck has identified himself as that actor and received the role when Stern and the studio couldn't agree on pay. Stern ultimately played Marv alongside Pesci's Harry in the 1990 film.
Roebuck told Entertainment Weekly that he spent one afternoon sitting with Pesci. "What Chris said to me when he fired me was that there was no chemistry," he said.
"And I reminded him that the characters literally spent a two-page scene together, and after that they were both being hit in the face with nails," he said. "So it didn't really matter what the chemistry was."
The production "did everything they could to get me to quit," Roebuck told the magazine. He said he has "enormous respect for Chris Columbus," although he considers the director's comments troubling.
Columbus recalled promising the actor "we'll work together at some point," though they did not.
In another interview, Roebuck told Page Six that after being fired, "I waited by the phone, man," but he has had no contact with Columbus since leaving the set. "I never, ever filmed anything with Joe Pesci," he told the outlet.
Roebuck asked Page Six how horrible he could have been "if I was the second choice for a $35 million movie." "It hurts my heart, and it hurts my heart that every Christmas I have to deal with this," he told Page Six.
Roebuck offered praise and criticism of Pesci to Entertainment Weekly, calling him "one of the greatest actors of the last 50 years but he's an angry guy," while describing himself as happy. Roebuck said Pesci told him after the firing that he also wished to be fired, using a profane description of the film.
Pesci's representative told the magazine that he respects everyone he works with, including talent and crew, and "would never participate in gossip like this."
Roebuck discussed his firing in earlier interviews. On Anchor Bay Entertainment's The Plank in 2024, he said he was "just a pawn in a game to get Daniel Stern." In a 2023 podcast appearance, he described a handshake from "Home Alone" writer-producer John Hughes as "the most disappointing handshake I ever received."
Roebuck, now 63, has credits that include "Lost," "Matlock" and "The Fugitive." He said he does not regret losing Marv because the role would have made him "too famous" and prevented him from getting other work.
"God's plan for you is very specific, so I was never going to be in Home Alone, ever," he said. He added that he hopes he and Columbus "could work together."
It was not immediately known whether Columbus would respond to Roebuck's account of the screen test.
Columbus is producing Robert Eggers' "Werwulf," which opens in theaters Dec. 25. He is also directing and co-writing "Gremlins 3," scheduled for release Oct. 6, 2028.





