Category: Technology Author : Duncan Riley Posted: November 13, 2008
Tags : firefox, firefox crashing, firefox memory issue, mozilla
Surprise! The memory issues are back in Firefox
Numerous users of the latest version of the Firefox web browser (3.0.4 released yesterday) are reporting memory issues causing the browser to freeze up or crash. Firefox 2 was plagued with memory management issues, but users had thought Mozilla had put these behind them with Firefox 3.
In my own case, Firefox 3.0.4 has become nearly unusable. The first couple of Firefox 3 releases were fine, and after years of complaining about the product, I couldn’t have been happier. Firefox 3.0.3 seemed a little more unstable, and although there were no clear memory leaks, I went from Firefox never crashing, to Firefox crashing maybe a couple of times a week. Now with Firefox 3.0.4, its a multi-day occurrence. The issue in the new release would appear to be memory related, with memory on my machine spiking over 100% for Firefox with only a handful of tabs open.
Now before Firefox fanboys do their usual trick and whine “it’s your plugins that are doing it” (which is the usual response, because it’s NEVER Firefox’s fault), I’ve tested the latest version of Firefox on three different Macs. My Quad Core Mac Pro with 4GB ram has a number of plugins installed, and I get the memory issue. My Macbook Pro with 2GB ram with 1 plugin installed has the memory issue. My wifes 6 month old Macbook with 1gb and ZERO plugins and really nothing else installed except Leopard HAS THE MEMORY ISSUE.
Here’s some comments on my original mention of the problem from both FriendFeed and Twitter
Its been crashing on me, a dozen times today, at least. – Dave Winer
crashing here too, and I’ve seen it eat all the memory as well
– Richard Walker
I’ve continually found FF to be the most constantly crashing browser I have, ever since ver 3. Barring using it’s add-ons for web development, have switched almost entirely to Chrome. – Robin Cannon
Crashed on both machines here in completing their auto update feature. FAIL – Paul W. Swansen
It’s become a crashing bore. Does Chrome work on Macs yet? – Abby Martin
Same problem here, and it’s driving me crazy. I want to use it for the addons, but I’ll go back to using Chrome if I need to. i have no complaints with chrome, except it doesn’t support my favorite addons yet. Does anyone know when that we will see a lot of addons for Chrome? – Michael Fidler
I number of users said they weren’t having issues, although the difference seems to be that the issue may be related primarily to the Mac version, although Inquisitr columnist Steve Hodson who doesn’t own a Mac has the same problem as well: details here on Winextra.
I’ve threatened before to dump Firefox over this issue, yet I’m still using it. Safari doesn’t offer the plugins which are the only reason I stick with it. I guess what saddens me more than anything, as a previous donor to Mozilla (so I’m not just a whining user) is that they never seem to learn. If only someone would come out with a Webkit based browser that supported Firefox plugins natively…..






![[Video] First 90 seconds of new Futurama hits the web, you excited?](http://www.inquisitr.com/wp-content/2010/06/futurama-sneak-peek-100x100.jpg)
Nov 13, 2008
Still using 2.something here and I don't really have any problems unless I spend a few hours on a flash site. (Actually not very hard to do thanks to Pandora…)
Nov 13, 2008
No kidding. Why does Firefox NOT use WebKit yet? Ego?
I've been using the nightly build of FF, which works well, except it crashes EVERY TIME I download a file. Filed a bug report. Meh. I just use Safari to download stuff.
Nov 13, 2008
A quick look a mozilla's bugzilla shows a ton of posts on the issues, ranging from the memory usage .) to the crashes. Whatever the final issue is, its apparent something is badly broken in the thing. I personally don't have any issues with the stable build (the nightly build crashed every time I tried to use google docs).
Nov 14, 2008
Why doesn't it use WebKit? Cause none of you seem to understand that the core of the expansibility of Firefox stems from it using Gecko.
I'm using 3.1 beta, and except for the download issue, (which i have solved by using FlashGot and an external tool to download things) I have no complaints.
Gecko is fine, it's being slimmed down all the time, and will hopefully live up to expectations with the 2.0 version of the engine.
Nov 14, 2008
3.0.4 installed for two days , no crashes for me.
Gato
Nov 14, 2008
I am having trouble reaching their add-ons page today. Is the problem on my end or theirs?
Nov 14, 2008
get a PC!
Nov 14, 2008
the memory issues are also terrible on linux.
On windows, I have no problem at all. It's a shame that a browser that is supposed to be universally cross-platform is not. Mozilla consistently refuses to do proper development for any platform other than Windows/Intel.
Nov 14, 2008
Firefox has been created a lot of problems lately. I am going to stop use it.
Nov 14, 2008
Just use opera
Losta features, low memory footprint, fast.
Nov 14, 2008
I hate FF for doing this! But i won't stop using it! Will perhaps shift to Opera for a while!
Nov 15, 2008
Stopped using FF a long time ago because of the bloatedness of this browser. With growing number of very capable alternatives FF team need to sort this out…
Nov 17, 2008
I am running Windows FireFox too and have been experiencing more crashes with 3.0.4 than I have ever had in my entire relationship with Firefox.
Nov 19, 2008
Since I am on Mac I really learned to live without all the plugins I used before and Webkit became my weapon of choice, except when doing dev work.
The slick, no thrills approach even made Chrome my main browser on Windows. Admitted, I miss the occasional plugin, but not that much either.