Category: Movies Author : Duncan Riley Posted: January 2, 2009
Tags : , , ,
Subscribe: Tech Feed, Email, Twitter

Valkyrie Producers May Be Sued Over Hitler Globe; Copyright Law Gone Mad


    StumbleUpon Digg Reddit Mixx del.icio.us MySpace Fark Facebook TwitThis Propeller Wikio Yahoo! Buzz

hitler-globe

The producers of Valkyrie, Tom Cruise’s newest movie based on the plot during World War Two to kill Hitler may be sued for using a reproduction of the famous Hitler Globe.

The globes, produced in the 1930’s were given to high ranking officials in the Third Reich, with one Globe said to be kept at Berchtesgaden (The Eagles Nest), the Bavarian Country home of Hitler. Most were destroyed during the war, but the Berchtesgaden Globe was retrieved by American soldiers.

Art collector Robert Pritikin acquired the globe in 2007 and filed a copyright claim over reproductions, ostensibly to stop neo-Nazi’s creating copies, and this is where the problem for Valkyrie lies: they didn’t seek permission from Pritikin to use the globe reproduction first.

According to Page Six, the Globe is actually up for sale, the Pritikin is said to be hoping the matter will be resolved without going to court…or better still Tom Cruise will buy the globe.

Sadly though it’s a case of copyright law gone mad. This is a work created in the 1930’s by a German company that no longer exists; that an art collector can claim copyright over the work in 2007 when the work, under both US and German law should be in the public domain is scary within itself. Worse still though, the copyright claim means that an historical event, and portrayal of that event based on facts, is now limited by copyright law, even events that occurred over 60 years ago. Imagine for example a copyright claim over parts of the US Civil War, the US War of Independence, or the Battles of World War One? That we despise Hitler is irrelevant: history needs to be free so that we are able to remember it freely, copyright law has no place here at all. It’s yet another sickening example of how copyright law has been corrupted by greed and blatant disregard for the common good.


You might also like




  • Terryeo
    Copyright laws stand to reward those who create. But in this situation, no one is harmed. One could argue the copyrighted object's value has increased, rather than being devalued, when reproduced.
  • bob dobbs
    Yeah sure Terryeo, if Scientology owned the copyright on that globe and someone used it without paying ,Scientology would pursue that person to the ends of the earth, with 10 lawyers and damn any legal costs.
    Since Tom is the poster boy of Scientology he can do no wrong though, paying this guy probably would'nt
    be stealing food from the mouths of Tom's children, but L Ron Hubbard said,

    In view of the fact that the HASI holds copyrights for
    all such material, and that a scientific organization of materials
    -54-


    can be copyrighted and therefore owned. The least that could be
    done to to such an area is the placement of a suit against them for using
    materials of Scientology without authority. Only a member of the
    HASI or a member of one of the churches affiliated with the HASI
    has the authority to use this information. The purpose of the suit
    >> is to harass and discourage rather than win.
    >>
    >> The law can be used very easily to harass, and enough harassment
    >> on somebody who is simply on the thin edge anyway, well knowing
    >> that he is not authorized, will generally be sufficient to cause his pro-
    >> fessional decease. If posible, of course, ruin him utterly.

    US District Court, Central District of California
    Fishman Case # 91-6426 HLH (Tx) Continued
    (Title page no number)
    MAGAZINE ARTICLES ON
    LEVEL

    0
    CHECKSHEET
    BY L RON HUBBARD
  • Doug@usa.com
    What kind of name is "Pritikin"? Chinese? Irish? Italian? Or is it one of the nice people next door who always seem to do something to make people hate them...?
  • Moishe
    Oy vey, Mr. "Pritkin" - you gotta love these people who are always looking out to make a "shekel" ...
  • Mr Industry
    >>but the Berchtesgaden Globe was retrieved by American soldiers.


    Don't you mean stolen?
blog comments powered by Disqus