Democrats have warned that Barrett's conservative leanings could lead to the overturning of Roe v. Wade, the landmark legal decision that established a woman's right to an abortion. However, they have refrained from insinuating that Barrett's Catholicism could play a role in her decision making.
According to Maher, this was a mistake. The comedian called on Democratic lawmakers to be more aggressive and attack the judge's faith.
"Democrats have to stop talking about packing the Supreme Court because it's already packed. With Catholics," he said, adding that he has "nothing against Catholics, except my entire upbringing."
Maher went on to argue that Catholic individuals are overrepresented on the highest courts, slamming pundits and commentators for even debating whether Barrett wants to overturn Roe v. Wade.
He likened the judge to the Terminator, describing her as a "robot programmed to fulfill one task. Except she wasn't sent from the future, she was sent from the past."
Maher concluded the segment by strongly urging Democratic leaders to make religion an issue.
"Amy Barrett said this week she had no strong feelings about climate change, but is very concerned about large belt buckles. Chuck Schumer said Democrats won't make Barrett's religion and issue, but they should. Because being nuts is relevant."