On the most recent episode of the Bravo reality show, the group—which also includes Lisa Rinna, Dorit Kemsley, Erika Girardi, Denise Richards, and Garcelle Beauvais—played a “game” in which they were to reveal their first impressions of one another, per E! News.
After a series of carefully worded niceties between some of the Housewives, Sutton was brutally honest and told Teddi that when she first met her, she thought she would be “a little boring.” While the accountability coach tried to awkwardly laugh the comment off, Sutton wasn’t finished.
“Are we supposed to be honest or not?” she quipped.
Sutton went on to clarify that was simply her “first impression,” then added that when she found out Teddi was also pregnant, her reaction was, “God help us!” She included an eye roll and threw her head back for effect.
Sutton then tried to turn the diss around.
“You’re way more interesting than I thought,” she told the daughter of rock legend John Mellencamp.
But things escalated as talk turned to Teddi’s upcoming retreat and how she told the ladies that she “didn’t care” if they came or not. A hormonal Teddi ultimately broke down in tears and left the dinner table. And while Sutton later tried to apologize for offending her, it was clear Teddi was not in a forgiving mood. Sutton later admitted she didn’t regret what she said because it was the truth.
In comments to Teddi Mellencamp’s Instagram post about the episode, several fans said it’s already time for Sutton to “go.”
“First impression is that Sutton is a big meanie. I hope I’m wrong,” one supporter wrote.
“Sutton needs to go! Hope she’s not on there all season,” another viewer said.
“I can’t even imagine being pregnant and having to deal with all that bullsh*t,” another fan wrote to Teddi.
And on Twitter, fans noted that Sutton’s constant rehashing of Teddi’s awkward retreat invite is already getting old. The wealthy party planner was also called out for her insincere apology to the veteran Housewives star.
“If Sutton was ‘uncomfortable’ or sorry she would’ve gone after Teddi to apologize sincerely,” one Twitter user wrote. “She’s not uncomfortable, she knows exactly what she’s doing! Game on ladies, Teddi’s down, who is next!”
Real Housewives of Beverly Hills fans know that Sutton was recently demoted to a “Friend” of the Housewives instead of a full-time cast member on the Bravo reality show.