In what looks to be a nice blow-up to start the week with the fine folks over at Fluther.com, a web question and answer site, have posted a public letter to Jason Calacanis the high flying owner of Mahalo, another Q&A site, on their blog telling him to stop stealing their questions. In this story of battling Q&A sites it seems that questions that have been posted to the Fluther site and posted to Twitter with attribution and a link back to the Fluther site are also showing up on the Mahalo site – but without any attribution or links.

As far as the guys at Fluther are concerned this is stealing and they want Calacanis to stop it

Stop stealing our users’ content. Your Q&A website, Mahalo Answers, is hijacking content from our Q&A site, Fluther, and breaking our terms of service.

We get it. You need to create doppelganger Twitter accounts to bolster your user base and create content. Perhaps some Twitter users are fine with the fact that their tweets are being co-opted by you to drive traffic. But we won’t allow you to strip out the attribution to our users simply to pad your own corpus of questions.

Here is the email exchange between Fluther and Calacanis as posted to the blog

[1] Letter from Jason Calacanis
From: Jason McCabe Calacanis
Date: Fri, May 29, 2009 at 3:35 PM
Subject: Re: Stop hijacking our content
To: Ben Finkel

Thanks for the email.

We don’t autoscrape questions, but our users can answer questions from the public timeline on Twitter… those publicly asked questions can be answered by anyone, anywhere at any time based on fair use (ie including on twitter or a person’s blog).

In other words, we don’t feel you can copyright a publicly asked questions.

However, I respect your right to disagree with my position.

All the Best, jason
—————
XXXXXX@Calacanis.com | Mobile: XXX-XXX-XXXX
http://www.calacanis.com | http://www.mahalo.com
Executive Assistant: XXXX@calacanis.com

From: Ben Finkel
Date: Fri, 29 May 2009 14:34:31 -0700
To:
Subject: Stop hijacking our content
Dear Mr. Calacanis,

I’m writing this letter to inform you that your Q&A website, Maholo Answers, is hijacking content from our Q&A website, Fluther.com. Apparently you’re scraping content from Twitter, including our questions, and reposting them as yours without attribution or links back to our website (a clear breech of our terms of service).

Please delete all content associated with the user “fluther” and cease and desist this practice immediately.

Ben Finkel
Fluther.com Co-Founder & CEO

–
Tap the collective.
http://www.fluther.com

There you have it folks, the newest battleground of the web – the Q&A Battle for Questions.

Calacanis told to quit stealing content is a post from: The Inquisitr

Jason Calacanis’ Mahalo has added Twitter support to its question and answer service Mahalo Answers.

The new feature allows anyone to ask a question of the service by sending the question to @answers on Twitter. Submitted questions are automatically posted to Mahalo Answers, and users are given a direct URL link for the page the question resides on.

The service of course is only as good as the replies the questions receive, and at least so far I couldn’t find any answers to questions that had been submitted via Twitter. Mahalo Answers also works on a payment system; you can ask a free question, but monetized questions get priority, and obviously the Twitter submitted ones don’t have that advantage.

You can read more about Mahalo Answers here.

Mahalo adds Twitter support to Answers service is a post from: The Inquisitr

The following is reprinted with permission from Jason Calacanis.

Last Monday we launched a new product called Mahalo Answers
(http://www.mahalo.com/answers/ ).

It got a very warm reception from the press, users and the industry (investors, partners, etc). This was the most seamless and well-executed launch I’ve ever been involved in, so I thought I would share what I’ve learned about launching new products while it’s fresh in my mind.

In this email I discuss coming up with the idea or building the product–that’s almost a book’s worth of information (hint, hint , but I will discuss the moment from when the product is completed, through the beta test, generating buzz, the press tour and launch.

Background

Mahalo Answers is a knowledge exchange with a virtual currency that can be exchanged for real dollars. In other words, it’s a question and answer site like Yahoo! Answers (which was based on the Korean knowledge services by Naver.com or Daum.net), that you can make money from. Users offer a tip that can be rescinded, but rescinded tips are tracked to warn researchers of possible dead beats.

There is no risk to offering a tip as it’s refundable and because multiple users will answer your question and you only have to give a tip to one person. You don’t have to offer a tip,, mind you, but it helps: in the first week questions with a tip were answered in half the amount of time as those without (approximately 30 minutes compared to 64).

For context, this is the third of Mahalo’s five pillars. The first two pillars were our human-selected search results and our Wikipedia-style “Guide Notes.” The other two pillars will launch in 2009. In other words, after almost two years of work we’ve build 60% of what Mahalo will eventually become. So, in three years we will have launched all five products–in some ways companies–in order to reach our goal of building the world’s first “human-powered search engine.”

Now, on to the process.

Creating Buzz: the Beta

In order to create buzz I like to start telling folks about my work schedule about a month out from the launch. On the past couple of trips I started telling folks that I was crushed (true!) trying to finish up “Project A.” At various cocktail parties, meetings and speaking gigs I talked about Project A. When folks asked what it was I told them it was a new product launching on December 15th. We showed some investment bankers and investors, knowing they like to chatter about who’s working on interesting things. Additionally, I started twittering Project A’s impending arrival both in this newsletter and on Twitter.

Many of you played along, responding back to me on Twitter and email and for that, I thank you.

(editors note: apologies about the formatting from this point)

The Beta

A couple weeks before the project’s launch we put up a simple Google
Spreadsheet with a bunch of questions. Some of the questions were
important (like what topics do you like), others were red herrings
(like what games do you like to play). In a week about 3,000 signed up
for the beta. We put an NDA at the top of the beta and we started
letting in a handful of people after *personal* emails from me asking
them not to disclose what we were doing and that they were under
official “FrienDA.” People *might* break an NDA if it’s simply text on
a webpage, but I don’t see them doing that if a friend invites them
in.

Additionally, I asked my staff to put their parents and spouses on the
system provided they were NOT in the industry. This is a great way to
get feedback from normal folks, and it’s great for me to get bonus
points with my staff’s parents (“oh… that CEO boss of yours is such
a nice gentleman for letting us see that new product.” — say that
like an overprotective mother for extra effect .

In the beta we discussed the type of community we wanted to have and
we put a thin line across the top of the page that instructed users to
simply email feedback at mahalo.com with their feedback. No stupid forms
to fill out–just click and send. I had the feedback email forwarded
to *every* single employee. Why? If there are problems everyone needs
to know about them and get flooded with them over and over again. The
feedback at mahalo.com email is punishment for when we suck–it’s our
penance. Want to get less email? Fix the problems in the beta!

Side note: I’ve told every member of our team at Mahalo that you MUST,
as a requirement of your job, have a phone with email. If you’re going
to be at a startup you need to be seeing the “Mahalo Weather Report”
on your BlackBerry or iPhone 24×7 like I do. It’s like being a police
officer–you need to carry a piece with you even if you’re off duty in
case sh@#$t goes down. It’s just part of the job.

For the folks who we didn’t get into the beta we sent them a coupon
for five Mahalo dollars to spend in the system. It’s good to do
something nice to the folks who signup but you can’t accommodate if
you do, in fact, have too many beta testers. Many of you took me up on
that offer.

Slamming the System

It is absolutly essential that you try to break your system before
users come in. I do a lot of simple things like throw bad characters
into web forms or load up 300 web pages at once in Opera and see what
happens. Of course, the tech team can do so much more with the tools
they have. You have to make twice as much time for testing load and
attacks as you think. We got some hacker friends to try and break a
demo copy of the site during the beta, we ran huge attacks against the
system and we maxed out all our infrastructure…

… and still it wasn’t enough!

We had to put another dozen servers online during the launch and we’ve
been up 99% of the time it seems–more than I could ask for for week
one.

The Media Tour (in six acts)

We do 10 media tours a year–at least. These occur under two
circumstances: we are launching a new product or we are doing a
speaking gig in another city. When we were in Sydney, Tokyo, Seoul,
London and Athens this past year we did a blogger dinner and a press
tour. These are invaluable for Mahalo as we’ve actually seen traffic
increases in those countries we visit. If you want to court early
adopters on a global basis do a press tour when you travel. It doubles
the value of your speaking gigs.

[[ If you want to skip to the bottom of the email you can see the
press clippings. ]]

Step One: Selecting who to brief.

Before launching a new product I like to show the product to select
bloggers and journalists. We keep a list in a Google Spreadsheet of
all of our contacts from around the world and when we do a press tour
we look to see which of these folks did a fair job reporting on our
last product. If they really took some time to understand the product
and write an accurate report on it we send them a short note asking
them if they would like to be briefed. We keep it very simple: “We’re
launching a new product and we would love to show it to you over the
phone in the next couple of days. If you’re interested and you could
give me a couple of available times on Wednesday, Thursday or Friday
we’ll set something up.”

Simple. One or two sentences and done. If they don’t respond we might
send one follow-up, but we don’t call and we don’t spam the person
over and over. That looks really desperate and it is not very
gracious. If they’re interested they will let you know, if they don’t
get back to you they are not. Don’t call them over and over to
“confirm they got the email.”

Step Two: Have your hardware and phone perfect.

We set up two computers for every demo. One with Adobe Connect as the
host and one connected as a user. Both computers are right next to
each other on the desk. This allows me, as the person giving the demo,
to actually see what they’re seeing. If the desktop sharing software
is slow or has a problem, I know. I can also pace my discussion to
match what they are seeing. We use a professional headset and phone
system–not a mobile phone. We have the journalists’ phone numbers and
we call them so we know we are getting a great, clean phone line.

Step Three: What to put in your demo.

Before we talk to a journalist we check to see what they’ve written
about Mahalo so we know where we should start the demo. If they’ve
done four stories we don’t need to explain that it’s a human-powered
search engine. This is our job to find out what they’ve covered, not
their job. If they have not covered Mahalo I start by asking folks how
much they know about Mahalo and if they would like me to give them a
brief 10,000-foot view. If they say yes I explain to them: why we
started Mahalo, what we’ve accomplished and what we’ve learned–the
good and bad. I give them specific facts including when we launched,
when we raised capital and how many monthly uniques we have according
to what source (i.e. Quantcast quantified or ComScore’s B.S. numbers
that no one should trust). Give these facts simply and don’t spin
them: fact, fact, fact. Journalists need facts in order to write
stories and in order to form opinions and follow-up questions. It’s
not your job to give them conclusions, it’s your job to give them
facts.

After establishing a baseline about the company I explain what we’re
launching in one sentence and why we’re launching it. In the case of
Mahalo Answers I said: “We’re launching a knowledge exchange similar
to Yahoo! Answers, Naver or Daum.net, that has a couple of very unique
features. This is a new feature we’ve added to Mahalo’s search pages
to make them more comprehensive and helpful–we are NOT changing
direction. We’re still a search engine.” At this point the journalist
will probably ask, “how is it different,” at which point you say
“we’ll let’s take a look.”

We then go into the major points that we want to get across. In the
case of Mahalo Answers we had four:

1. Mahalo’s search results contain three items: curated links (like
Google), content (like Wikipedia or About.com), and Q&A (like Naver
Knowledge In or Yahoo! Answers). We believe the future of search is
having these three things on one page.

2. Mahalo Answers has a virtual currency that allows you to “tip” a
user if they give a good answer. Tips are refundable, can be funded
for as little as $1 and users can convert Mahalo Dollars to US
dollars, less a 25% fee. That 25% fee along with advertising is how we
make money.

3. Users can ask other users direct questions with a tip or without.

4. Answers can include rich media like a YouTube video, an mp3 file or
a Flickr photo. These are added by simply putting in the URL of the
object–not the embed code.

Step Four: Letting the journalist ask questions.

I leave it up to the journalist as to when they want to ask questions.
After every point I ask “did you have any questions about [[insert
point here]], or would you like me to keep going?” They will ask you a
question or say “keep going.” It’s up to them how they want to ask a
question, not you. Keep moving if they don’t have questions. Some
journalists like to take it all in, or they might be eating a sandwich
at their desk and have you on mute. Either way, give them the option.

Step Five: Wrapping up.

At the end I like to recap the basic points, let them know that we’re
excited about the launch and let them know we have a couple of new
features coming. If they are a smart journalist they will try to
extract one of these new features. If they guess it right I tell them,
if they don’t I don’t tell them. It’s a little game I like to play at
the end which is: if you ask good questions you get rewarded with
better nuggets for your story. At the end I thank them for taking the
time and tell them my email address in case they have any questions or
suggestions at any time. I don’t tell them to talk to a PR person or
contact marketing. If they have a question email me immediately and
I’m available to them. Why? Because when you’re on f@#$%ing deadline
it’s a real pain in the ass to have to talk to a @!#$% PR person to
get a simple question answered. Sorry, I was just remembering my days
as a journalist where I REFUSED to go through PR people and told them
if they wanted INK in Silicon Alley Reporter their CEO needed to talk
to me on email. This made PR people crazy, but it made Silicon Alley
Reporter great.

Step Six: Leave them alone.

Do NOT call the journalist to ask them how their story is going or ask
to see the piece in advance. That looks desperate and insulting. If
they take the time to do a piece great, if not at least you know they
are aware of your product for the next time. 90% of the reason folks
hate PR people is because they always act so desperate and act so
annoying. NEVER call a journalist. Period. Just send them short emails
and leave them alone.

Opening the Floodgates

We set an embargo of 1 a.m. PST for Mahalo Answers and we opened up
the product at around 1:30 a.m. We tried to get it to open at 12:55
a.m. but there were–as there always are–some technical issues. We
had a bunch of little problems throughout the night, but had them
worked out when the sun came up.

The entire tech team came in Sunday night as well as half the
editorial team (the other half slept so they could work the next day
obviously). We got a couple of boxes of Stan’s Donuts from Westwood
(peanut butter and chocolate… wha-what?!) and caffeined up for the
night. It was an amazing bonding experience and it was super exciting.
At around 4 a.m. we did a little toast with some sparkling apple
cider, and later that week I packed the team on a big old bus and took
them to Disneyland. One of the gossip blogs took me to task for taking
everyone to Disneyland after having layoffs, but I believe you gotta
work hard and play hard. A day out at Disneyland is a simple reward
for six weeks of non-stop work.

The first day we put three folks on the “sheriff tools” with
instructions to delete any stupid questions or answers, and obviously
spam. We wanted to set a tone in the first week that unhelpful
answers, joking, or obnoxious behavior were NOT the point of Mahalo
Answers. At one point someone sent me (probably one of you!) a long
email trying to figure out why the quality of the answers was so high.
I responded “because we delete the bad ones.”

Membership in an online community is a privilege, not a right. If you
run an online community I suggest removing people who act obnoxious or
stupid–especially early on. Obnoxious folks drive away considered
folks–which is exactly why I left blogging. There simply were too
many obnoxious folks who make their living pissing on the legs of the
folks trying to do something intelligent. Sure, if you piss on a
brilliant person’s leg everyone at the party will notice you, but they
will do so for all the wrong reasons. Anyway, let’s not get into the
de-evolution of the blogosphere or you’ll have to read–and I’ll have
to write–another 3,000 words.

Setting the Tone

Back to setting the tone. It’s absolutely important that when you have
a beta that your entire company take part in it and “eat your own dog
food” as they say. In Mahalo Answers we wanted answers that were more
intelligent than “why don’t you google it?” or “here’s the wikipedia
page.” So, we had our entire team spend days asking interesting
questions and answering them with considerable care and details. When
the users came in for the first time they were confronted with, as our
CTO Mark Jeffrey put it, a library-like environment. It was a serious
place and as such no one started screaming or acting like an idiot. If
they did we deleted their nonsense. Nothing is more effective in
getting rid of a troll than ignoring them and removing their garbage.
You should have no problem removing the bad actors from your system
because one bad actor can cost you, over their lifetime, thousands of
good actors.

In summary

This is how I like to launch a product and it’s not based on anything
I’ve read or been told to do. It’s simply one person’s process learned
from a decade of launching products. I’m sure there are many more
interesting ideas and I would love for you to send them to me so I can
learn from you. That really is the deal that you and I have with this
email experiment we’re doing: I tell you everything I know and I’ve
learned and you hit reply and tell me. We then create a relationship
based on trusting each other, sharing knowledge and support.

I look forward to hearing your tips… just hit reply and you should
see jason at calacanis.com in your “To:” field. I read 100% of emails
sent to me and I respond to at least 50%.

If I don’t speak to before the New York, all the best and let’s kick
some ass in the New year!

jason at calacanis.com

How To Launch A New Product is a post from: The Inquisitr

Jason Calacanis’ people powered search come uber blog Mahalo has launched Mahalo answers, a direct competitor to Yahoo Answers.

As is not unusual with a Calacanis project, Jason has once again taken an existing idea and put his own spin on it, with the belief that his take will reign supreme; Weblogs Inc was a take on blogging (and in part Gawker Media), Netscape (now Propeller) was a take on Digg, and Mahalo itself was a take on the original Ask Jeeves, but more heavily content oriented.

Mahalo Answers offers something of a blend of Yahoo Answers, WikiAnswers, Answers.com and the now dead Google Answers. The biggest difference upfront (again like all Calacanis projects) is the injection of money; like Google Answers before it, Mahalo Answers come with a financial rewards platform.

Unlike Google Answers, which many presumed proved that a paid answering service in a sea of free was not a viable service, Mahalo Answers is taking a hybrid route. At the top is a “tip” system where users can tip other users for the best answer. Like Google Answers this is a designated amount, and the system operates by deposit: those wanting an answer deposit money into Mahalo dollars (converted 1:1 with US Dollars), and those with the successful answer get paid out 75% of the nominated amount; the business model revolves around Mahalo taking a 25% cut in each successful question. Where it differs from Google Answers is in openness: Google Answers relied on a closed panel of “experts” to answer each question, and you only recieved one answer. Mahalo Answers is fully open, so anyone can answer a question with a dollar amount, and the best answer nominated by the person asking the question takes the loot. Calacanis says that this is a key difference: Mahalo Answers is an open platform which empowers users on both ends and is not overly controlled, creating a marketplace of open competition and best practice.

An interesting twist is the ability to ask questions of other users directly. For example I could ask Jason why he is obsessed with bulldogs for $2, and if he answers he gets paid. This moves the service in part into oDesk/ Scriptlance and similar services territory, and Calacanis is aware of this as well. Mahalo Answers comes with a services section that allows for outsourcing like questions; perhaps not quite into full blown project areas, but certain coding and similar realms.

But the service isn’t limited to paid questions. Like Yahoo Answers and similar services Mahalo Answers is completely free if you don’t want to pay for an answer, a key feature missing from Google Answers. However, paid questions get priority in index results, so if you want quality you’re encouraged to pay, but you don’t have to if you don’t want to.

I asked Calacanis about quality control, making note that Yahoo Answers has become a bit of a joke with trolls and rubbish Q&A’s. Jason pointed out that people are unlikely to pay for rubbish questions, and it’s the paid questions that get priority. Further to that though, rubbish questions will be removed from the results; they may not delete the questions, but they won’t be promoting them to the front page like Yahoo Answers often does.

One interesting take is the ability of people asking paid questions not to pay out if they don’t like the answers. Calacanis notes that each user does have the ability to pick no answer if they don’t like them, or likewise if they decide to use the answer but not pay out. However those decisions count towards a users profile, so anyone trying to game the system will be clearly flagged to those looking to provide a quality answer in return. Calacanis sees this as a give and take system, which rewards those who do the right thing.

There’s also a strong social aspect to the service. Either at launch, or shortly there after Mahalo Answers will also support Facebook, MySpace and blog widgets that will allow users to advertise their questions, or even their willingness to answer questions for a set amount. This takes Mahalo Answers into Skype paid consults territory somewhat, and should be an interesting draw in getting more people involved.

Conclusion

It’s important to note that Jason Calacanis, love him or hate him has a strong track record of success as noted previously. Jason sees the service as the third leg for Mahalo: they have the search and news (blog) legs, but out of 4.7 million uniques a month, their pages per visitor are below 2. Jason believes that people will keep coming back, and keep clicking on questions and answers, and with money involved they’ll happily participate.

I can’t help but be impressed by Mahalo Answers. The idea that people would pay for answers isn’t as flawed as the Google Answers experiment would lead many to believe. You only have to look at many, many outsourcing sites to see that basic questions often have a money value, even quick responses at below $10. The service is slick, well thought out, and there is much to like. Calacanis told me they will be backing the launch by giving Mahalo dollars away to both testers, and existing Mahalo account holders alike, and the injection will be in the vicinity of $200-250,000 to get the service rolling. With money like that to be had, people willing to answer questions for even a small return in this economic climate are bound to be plentiful. Mahalo Answers= WIN.

Mahalo Answers: a Yahoo Answers slayer? is a post from: The Inquisitr

According to Mashable, Yahoo found the service so successful in their India test launch that they’re extending the product for inclusion in US search results off main Yahoo.com search queries.

Ask.com went down the same route back in October, although Yahoo isn’t extending the layout to all results just yet.

First impressions are positive: it’s a great way to take in search results. However there is a catch: the results are traditional Yahoo style lame. In fact the results in Glue are worse than the Yahoo search results, and the site seems to be truly Mahalo style as results aren’t automatically generated (as they are with Ask.com) but come from a set of pre-determined results, possibly even added by humans. While that makes for decent pages for searches like Barack Obama, it’s useless past maybe the B or C list in the world of politics, countries and celebrities, but presumably this will improve with time.

UPDATE: Yahoo has been in contact with some corrections. Glue is completely standalone and not part of general search, and the results are delivered by algorithm. We apologize for getting these facts wrong, but I have to ask: if the results are computer generated, why isn’t there more of them? I did ask and the response was that they plan to “continue expanding the coverage for Glue Pages over time.” I should clarify at this point that I actually love the layout, just the lack of depth, which is lame. Hopefully they’ll ramp it up soon. This is the sort of thing that might deal Yahoo back into the search game.

Yahoo Glue: I can’t believe it’s not Mahalo! is a post from: The Inquisitr

Mahalo CEO Jason Calacanis blogged (ironically given that he publicly quit blogging) that the decision was due to the economic crisis and the expected reduction in online advertising growth.

The main job cuts have come from Mahalo’s editorial department, with Calacanis noting the switch towards “freelance positions over in-house editors.” Other savings will be made through reducing office space through renting desks; apparently Mahalo currently has 6 offices in Santa Monica.

Mahalo’s editorial staff were the backbone of the search side of Mahalo, so it’s no great surprise that their numbers have been cut, economic issues or not, given the switch of Mahalo to primarily a blog content play. If the switch to freelancers sounds familiar it should be: it’s how Calacanis grew Weblogs Inc, driving the establishment of “blogging jobs” back in the days where such positions rarely existed.

His bizarre I’m not blogging anymore PR stunt aside, Calacanis knows blogging and knows how to get the most from bloggers at low rates of pay compared to full time employees, so although others may be skeptical about Mahalo’s chances, I’m not one of those people. The cuts make sense, even if we feel bad for those who are out of a job today.

Mahalo cuts 10% of workforce is a post from: The Inquisitr

The new Mahalo adopts the magazine style layout currently popular in the blogosophere, aggregating news stories in a layout that is part Google News. There’s even a “live blog” right of screen, which is updated with links to breaking news outside of Mahalo by members of the Mahalo team.

When Ask.com relaunched last week and we discussed the similarities to Mahalo, the biggest difference I noted then was that Mahalo offered stale, out of date links, vs Ask.com offering the latest content. This hasn’t really been addressed by these changes, at least with the search results. Our example before was the Mahalo page for Angelina Jolie being woefully out of date with news links, and that is still the case today. Instead Mahalo has switched to a blog content first model that creates new entries (really blog posts) for big stories, rich with keywords, then uses the original search pages for contextual links within each post.

Mahalo has been slowly moving toward becoming a blog now for some time, having already abandoned its focus on quality search results, instead offering comment and content with those results. That the site has seemingly abandoned its search starting point may speak poorly of the model to start with, but Calacanis is the sort of guy who is’nt afraid to change direction if things aren’t working, and he wealth of experiencing in blogging that will help Mahalo establish itself as a leading blog. Certainly numbers from Compete and Alexa show Mahalo flat-lining (Quantcast shows growth to the end of August…and then a drop), so kudos to Jason for taking the plunge and trying something new.

(in part via Cnet)

Mahalo now officially a blog is a post from: The Inquisitr

Ask.com has relaunched its search engine with a new emphasis on quality grouping based on likely related topics.

The new engine is said to have been rebuilt from the ground up, with traditional results being displayed with “structured” sources of data in certain categories like entertainment, health and jobs. Questions will also be answered through the delivery of results from Answers.com and Yahoo Answers.

Ask.com’s Jim Safka told the NY Times that the new Ask.com “is faster and returns more relevant results for common queries than in the past” and that “Some of the best content is coming from individuals, not necessarily from professional publishers,” which is good news for bloggers and other small scale web publishers.

The grouping works. A search for Angelina Jolie starts with a short bio, pic, and relevant links in a cluster. You then get two additional results, images from Ask.com and an IMDB link. Next up is a latest news cluster, then TV listings after that again. Parts of the results you already get in Google (in particular news, images and video), but what it looks more like is another service: Mahalo.

The Jason Calacanis founded search engine come content play offers pre-bundled results with an aim to deliver related links people are looking for…pretty much the same use case Ask.com is targeting. Mahalo uses “guides” to generate their pages, so in theory the end results should be more user friendly, and certainly the break down into usable clusters is more thorough than what Ask.com is offering. But likewise, Mahalo has a distinct disadvantage: the need for human updating. On the Angelina Jolie query, the latest news link on Mahalo (at the time of writing) is dated May 28, vs Ask.com at 1 hour. The divide then comes down to not the quality of links, but use case relevance: is a user going to find Mahalo more attractive because it offers better bundling, or Ask.com that offers refresher results, including links to the latest news or gossip.

I’d bet that someone is going to call Ask.com a Mahalo killer, but that person isn’t me. On its original model that was focused primarily on search results, Ask.com would have been a big blow, but Mahalo has changed over time, and today it is part blog-like content play with some obvious SEO benefits in itself, rather than simply the “human-powered search engine” it once was. That, and both sites don’t have strong crossover, so the substitution of use model doesn’t really come into play…well, not significantly anyway.

Ask.com revamp smells like Mahalo is a post from: The Inquisitr