Looks like things aren’t “Cool for the Summer” for Demi Lovato anymore. Sleigh Bells, an indie pop/rock group, filed a lawsuit on Monday alleging that Lovato stole their riffs and illegally sampled their songs without permission. The group noted that Demi Lovato’s song “Stars” from her 2015 album Confident resembled their tracks “Infinity Guitars” and “Riot Rhythm.”
In the court documents, Sleigh Bells noted that Lovato’s song and “Infinity Guitars” are “virtually identical content” that “transcend the realm of coincidence.” As of press time, Lovato has not issued a statement regarding the lawsuit.
This isn’t the first time that the band has targeted Demi Lovato over the tracks’ similarities. After Lovato released Confident last fall, the band reached out to Demi regarding the issue. Instead of contacting Lovato privately, Sleigh Bells chose to send a public tweet to the singer. Several of Lovato’s fans responded to the tweet, urging the band to contact Demi’s representatives instead of airing the grievance on Twitter.
.@ddlovato Demi Lovato flattered you guys sampled Infinity Guitars & Riot Rhythm for "Stars" but we were not contacted. Gotta clear those.
— SLEIGH BELLS (@sleighbells) November 2, 2015
Demi Lovato did not respond via Twitter, and declined to comment. However, two of her producers reached out to Entertainment Weekly to try to clear up the issue. “We did not use any samples in Demi Lovato’s song ‘Stars.’ Demi was also not involved with the production. She only wrote top line.”
A simple listen to Lovato’s and Sleigh Bells’ songs reveals that they certainly have their similarities. Here is the audio of “Stars” by Demi Lovato:
And for comparison, here’s “Infinity Guitars” by Sleigh Bells. The track was released five years before Lovato’s song.
The similarities are audible within the first verse of Lovato’s “Stars”; the song features an intense, rhythmic drum sequence that has been looped. The drum sequence in “Infinity Guitars” has the same pace and rhythm, and similarly underscores the verses. There are also a few differences: the drums in Lovato’s song have been distorted and warped with added vocals, while the “Infinity Guitars” drums are only accompanied by handclaps. Additionally, the vocals on the songs are similarly delivered: Lovato and Sleigh Bells vocalist Alexis Krauss both chant their verses, snarling their way through tough-girl lyrics.
“Riot Rhythm,” on the other hand, hardly bears any resemblance to Lovato’s track. The two songs both feature a ricocheting guitar riff, but the riff in Lovato’s song is only a few notes long and is much more muted.
So, is it possible that Demi is in serious trouble? According to Jeff Peretz, a music professor at New York University, probably not. “Basically, when people who know the Sleigh Bells song hear the Demi Lovato song, will they be confused in thinking that they’re hearing the Sleigh Bells song? I don’t think that’s the case… [It’s] not close enough to the line to be against the law.” According to Peretz, Demi Lovato’s track “goes to a pop-style chord progression and [‘Infinity Guitars’] doesn’t, so they’re not the same, mathematically speaking.”
This isn’t the first time Demi Lovato has been hit with accusations of stealing. In June of 2015, fans noted the similarities between Katy Perry’s hit “I Kissed A Girl” and Lovato’s song “Cool for the Summer.” Lovato responded to the accusation via Twitter saying the songs did not sound similar and that “more than one female artist can kiss a girl and like it…”
@etnow sounds nothing like it and with all the advances we've made in the LGBT community…
— Demi Lovato (@ddlovato) July 1, 2015
@etnow I think more than one female artist can kiss a girl and like it….. ????
— Demi Lovato (@ddlovato) July 1, 2015
Demi Lovato is currently in the middle of her summer-long “Future Now” arena tour with Nick Jonas. Sleigh Bells just did a set at the Billboard Hot 100 Festival this past weekend and will embark on a tour starting in September.
[Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images]